Wednesday, August 9, 2023

58 Summers Ago: Amazing Spider-Man Annual # 2

Note: This post was originally published on July 20th, 2015. It has been revised and expanded with new content and information, so even if you read it all those years ago, take another look. You won't be disappointed!  

Fifty eight years ago comic book specialty stores didn’t exist. Instead, you had to saunter over to the neighborhood newsstand, candy store or luncheonette to purchase the latest comics (if none of those establishments sound familiar to you I suspect you're under thirty!). The Marvel Comics Group was in full swing in 1965, with superstar artists/creators Jack Kirby, Wally Wood and Steve Ditko producing superior work under editor/writer Stan Lee. If you were an aficionado who followed any of Marvel’s output, letters pages and house ads would have announced the upcoming Annuals which were published every spring and summer, a time chosen specifically to coincide with kids being off from school. The reasoning being they'd have a few extra quarters to spend (often attained by doing extra chores around the house or selling pretzels on street corners - which was how my older brother John and cousin Jack paid for their comics!), while taking a family vacation or sitting under a tree with a coke on a lazy afternoon. In that long ago summer of '65 Amazing Spider-Man Annual # 2 leaped off the racks, falling into the hands and back pockets of many a youth. 


The understated simplicity of Ditko’s cover included what would become an iconic Spider-Man image; the full-figure pose was used as the corner symbol on the monthly Amazing Spider-Man title for years after Ditko had parted ways with Marvel. The bold coloring, likely by Stan Goldberg, compliments Ditko’s images. Spider-Man’s red/blue costume contrasts perfectly with the yellow background, purple logo and red/orange/white captions and corner box. Sam Rosen’s attractive lettering completes the picture.   

 In “The Wondrous Worlds of Dr. Strange!” Steve Ditko brought together two of his signature characters. Although this was a Ditko plotted tale (with Stan Lee dialogue and editing) it is possible the Annual may have been discussed months in advance, when Lee and Ditko were still communicating with each other (according to Ditko sometime before Amazing Spider-Man # 25 Lee stopped talking to him. To learn more about Ditko's side of the story I urge everyone to purchase The Four Page Series # 9, which can be ordered here):


But in a letter by Ditko written to fan Glen Johnson in 1965, as seen in The Hero # 37, Summer 2023 (published by Robin Snyder) Ditko wrote: 

"It's a little difficult to give you the coming spider adventures because it's a continued story and the major villain's identity is not revealed in the beginning. I was going to use this for the Annual but when Marvel planned so many reprints and only 20 pages or so available for a new spider adventure and that not being enough to tell the whole story I decided to revise it and use it over a 3 issue spread because it would fit in very well with the issue where Pete goes to College."    

                                         Amazing Spider-Man # 31, December 1965

This could have been the splash page to Amazing Spider-Man Annual # 2, but when Ditko discovered he didn't have 40-odd pages to play with he wisely scrapped that idea and expanded it into one of the most acclaimed storylines, spanning over three issues of the monthly title (#'s 31-33). As comics fan/analyst Joe Frank noted in the letters section of The Hero # 37, "This way may have worked out better giving readers a full month to worry between episodes." I agree wholeheartedly, Joe!   

To read more of Ditko's letter on his future plans for Spider-Man and Doctor Strange, further commentary from the erudite Joe Frank, and other surprises, I once again direct you to this site: http://ditko.blogspot.com/p/ditko-book-in-print.html   

With one avenue closed Ditko rethought his options and explored another direction; one that would work to greater advantage with a shorter page count. In retrospect, the choice seems odd, since Ditko often stated his dislike of using guest stars, contending that it undercut the individuality of a superhero:

Everyone used from another hero’s story-world prevented us from focusing on, creating and developing our own unique story-world of characters and villains like Dr. Octopus, Electro, Kraven, etc. And it affected S-m’s own cast—JJJ, Betty, Flash, Aunt May—such as Johnny Storm’s (HT) relationship with Peter and his classmates, etc. All outside, other inclusions robbed us of our unique potentials.”

Steve Ditko, A Mini-History “Guest-Stars: Heroes and Villains,” The Comics, Vol 14, No. 7 July 2003 

Ditko avoided this problem by choosing not to use any of the supporting characters (even Spider-Man fails to appear in his civilian identity of Peter Parker) setting the tale apart from the monthly continuity. Ditko explained his reasoning, speaking specifically about the Annual:

“A line has to be drawn for what is acceptable and not acceptable for a character. (I even had magic limits on Dr. Strange. Amazing Spider-Man Annual # 2 (1965) featuring Dr. Strange, was, as an annual should be, a special event. It does not necessarily have to connect with the monthly adventures. And Spider-Man was already long undercut with space aliens.” 

Steve Ditko, A Mini-History 1 “The Green Goblin,” The Comics Vol 12, No. 7, July 2001. 


Ditko's compositional skills, cityscape and seedy characters come to life on this page. The use of a vertical panel positions Spider-Man front and center as pedestrians go about their business on the street below.  



 Spider-Man enters the wildly imaginative dimensions Ditko created in Dr. Strange. A historical aside for any youngsters in the audience, please note that there was a time when you could ride a bus or subway for 15 cents, but you had to have change or a token - and Metro Cards didn't exist! (who says a blog on comics can't be educational?)

The plot centers on a sorcerer named Xandu, who seeks power by acquiring a magic wand, one half of which is owned by Dr. Strange. Two dimwitted thugs fall under Xandu's spell and assist him in his quest (what better way to involve Spider-Man?). Despite the odd nature of the tale, Spider-Man remained in character, cracking jokes while being flung into another dimension (one of Lee’s best lines: "It's gonna take more than a 15 cent bus ride to get me back to Forest Hills in New York!"). 


Dr. Strange discovers Spider-Man's presence during his mystic battle with Xandu in the last panel of page 15, building up the story's drama.   





The more mature Dr. Strange leads the confrontation, with Spider-Man backing him up.   

Ditko set parameters. Throughout most of the story Spider-Man and Dr. Strange were unaware of each other, fighting on different fronts. The heroes did not “meet” until the final panel of page 15 and appeared in only 13 panels together. They combined forces against Xandu in the final confrontation, the older, wiser Dr. Strange leading the fray. This would make sense following Ditko’s logic of what makes a successful team, citing Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson.    

“The more the unequal status is perceived and valid, the better the results as a team operation.” 

Steve Ditko, A Mini-History 6, "Spider-Woman/Spider-Girl”, The Comics Vol  13, No. 5 May 2002. 


Ditko's two unique heroes have a brief conversation before going their separate ways. The lettering on the word "friendship" is not by Sam Rosen, meaning the original word was replaced. Since this blog is titled "Marvel Mysteries and Comics Minutiae" I have to ask, what could it have replaced?

Ditko juggled the discordant elements of Spider-Man and Dr. Strange in a way that retained the integrity of both strips. Mood and color (likely supplied by Stan Goldberg), detailed buildings and arcane images, all combined to unusual effect. 

Given the page restrictions (20 as opposed to 41 pages) this story was considerably more offbeat, and the brief interaction between Ditko’s heroes was memorable. It was the last time Ditko included a guest-star in his Spider-Man and Dr. Strange stories. 


Reprint of the splash page from Amazing Spider-Man # 1, March 1963. Lettering by John D'Agostino under the pen name "Johnny Dee." His career included work as artist, inker and colorist and he lettered many of Ditko's stories for Charlton in the 1960s. Ditko's expressive hands showing emotion is at the forefront of this page. 

     
The "space aliens" Ditko referred to in the quote above was also reprinted in the Annual, originally presented in Amazing Spider-Man # 2, May 1963, "The Uncanny Threat of the Terrible Tinkerer!" Stan Lee plot and dialogue; Artie Simek letters. Although Ditko is correct that the sci-fi  elements, offshoots of Lee's Tales to Astonish and Journey into Mystery plots, are out of place in Spider-Man's world, the artist still invests energy and a quirky atmosphere to the yarn.   


While Ditko drew an exciting splash page (and included vignettes of Spider-Man's cast) Dr. Doom was too powerful a character to "realistically" confront a teenage hero. Characteristically for Ditko, Spider-Man doesn't defeat Doom; he flees when the Fantastic Four show up. Reprinted from Amazing Spider-Man # 5, October 1963.   

Amazing Spider-Man Annual # 2 had one drawback from the previous years effort; it (along with Marvel's other 1965 dated Annuals) included reprints in lieu of longer stories and features. A let-down, although to be fair a number of fans, yours truly included, did not own all the original comics and greatly enjoyed seeing them. The 1964 Amazing Spider-Man Annual had 72 interior pages of all-new material (with only the inside front, inside back and back covers consisting of advertising); Annual 2 featured 70 pages of story and art (two house ads for the Marvel line and MMMS products were included). Either due to time constraints or cost cutting the opening 20 page tale was followed by reprints from Amazing Spider-Man #'s 1, 2 and 5. As good as Ditko’s earlier work was - and it most assuredly had an immediate impact on this author, starting with ASM # 3 - his style evolved in a very short period of time, with a more assured confidence in storytelling, composition and inking by 1965.  

Following in the footsteps of the first annual, the Gallery of Spider-Man’s Foes continued. It included five full-page illustrations of Spider-Man’s rouges gallery, concurrent with his monthly title. Ditko’s mastery of pen and ink is evident in every line, and his clean, precise inking is a joy to behold.


The Ringmaster was originally a Simon and Kirby villain, dating back to Captain America Comics #5 (August 1941) and revised two decades later by Lee and Kirby in The Incredible Hulk #3 (September 1962). Ditko created most of the rouges gallery though, including the Clown and Princess Python, one of Ditko's more attractive females. Lettering by Sam Rosen.  

    

The Crime-Master was one of Ditko's most dramatic non-powered villains, a gangster straight out of a 1930s Warner Brothers movie. Ditko excelled at creating a world in his Spider-Man stories that consisted of sinister mobsters, threatening back alleys and lonely docks. The two-part story in Amazing Spider-Man #'s 26-27 (July-August 1965) which also featured the malevolent Green Goblin, remains a personal favorite. Copy by Lee; lettering by Sam Rosen.


This was the last Spider-Man annual produced by Steve Ditko (according to Ditko he was phoned by production man Sol Brodsky, who relayed the assignment of the 1966 special, but the artist had second thoughts about his future at Marvel and whatever he might have planned is a tantalizing question left to the ages. Several months after ASM Annual # 2 was published Ditko quit the company, never to draw his two signature characters again. The stories Ditko produced with Stan Lee in a four year period on Spider-Man and Dr. Strange are not just a nostalgic romp; many stand out as superior work woven by a master craftsman. It is an accomplishment that stands the test of time.  

    
The final caption in Amazing Spider-Man Annual #2 (reprinting Amazing Spider-Man #5) included new copy likely written by Stan Lee. One aspect of Ditko's work that is often ignored is his ability to create humorous situations. Peter Parker's bemused expression brought the character's personality to life in an endearing way for many young fans and was a refreshing change from the cardboard heroes that permeated comics in that period.      

16 comments:

  1. Nick, I fear that, if Ditko had been allowed to do things purely his way, Spidey may not have been the success that he was. Ditko didn't even like the character being called 'Spidey', for crying out loud. And no guest-stars? Why not? The FF helped sell ASM #1, so an occasional guest-star certainly wouldn't have hurt sales. I can see why Stan Lee may have gotten exasperated with his collaborator's insistence on doing things his own way. In fact, it's a wonder they managed to produce the number of issues they did, given the circumstances. I think Stan had the right idea about doing things - the success of Marvel Comics at the time proves that, although, naturally, Kirby, Ditko, Heck, etc., were also instrumental in that success. Stan was the leader 'though.

    I've got several printings of this tale, including the original ASM Annual #2 - it's an absolute belter. Now, pop over to my blog and identify the inker on the '60s Marvel posters. What do I pay you for? (Whaddya mean I don't? Oh well, that explains it then.)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nick, Greg Theakston did one of his Ditko reprint jobs a few years back that included a long interview with Ditko's studio-mate Eric Stanton, in which Stanton claimed that he and Ditko did a lot of assisting each other during the ~10 years they shared the studio space. Ditko is on record that Stanton came up with the idea of the web shooters in the creation of Spidey, for example, and there are many panels of Stanton's racy comics that sure as heck look like Ditko work.

    Anyway, Stanton made the claim that he did a lot of the artwork on Spidey Annual 2. But he did not elaborate. I assume that Ditko plotted the story, so maybe Stanton inked some? Filled in background work? This is a fascinating question that alas will now probably never be answered for sure: just how much did Stanton contribute to the Spidey-Strange teaming?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wallace Wood (where have I heard that name before? ) thanks for the kind words.

    Kid,
    Stan Lee was out to promote the entire Marvel line and did a sensational job in that area. Growing up I loved guest-stars and crossovers, although some made more sense than others.

    I can see both Lee and Ditko's point of view, and Ditko did go along with Lee for the most part, even if he did it his way (instead of working well together the two got in each others way. In issue 19 it was the police that nabbed Sandman).

    When done with a little thought the use of guest-stars was entertaining and may have helped sales. It was also easier to accomplish with limited titles. In later years it became a mess. And what do we have now? Dozens of characters appearing in titles like Avengers every month with no regard for continuity or common sense.

    ReplyDelete
  4. As studio mates stanton and Ditko very likely helped each other out when deadlines loomed. I can see Ditko inking/lettering on some of Stanton's bondage strips, and suspect Stanton assisted with inking on some of Ditko's Spidey and Dr. Strange stories. Annual 2 may have had some inking from Stanton but I see an awful lot of Ditko in the story.
    One correction. Ditko has never credited Stanton with the web shooter idea. In fact Ditko has said it was his idea. It may have been Stanton that made the claim.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for the article. A friend of mine, when I lived in Georgia, got me very interested in reading and collecting Marvel Comics in the summer of 1965. I believe he started the year earlier. I bought Amazing Spider-Man Annual 2 that summer along with Fantastic Four Annual 3 and JIM(Thor)Annual # 1. These three comics remain some of my favorites to this day. I had read on the internet of this friend's passing a few years back and had always remembered him for being instrumental in my collecting of comics. I haven't read comics in years, but do have a complete Marvel Masterworks collection that I read continuously. Great memories.

    ReplyDelete
  6. David, I'm glad you enjoyed the post. The discussion on Annuals always seems to trigger fond memories for many, myself included. If you check my archives you will notice its a summer tradition on my blog to write about annuals; last year I wrote about ASM Annual 1 and a few others as well. Feel free to post your thoughts on them as well.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Amazing Spider-man Annual 2 will always remain a favorite of mine due to the use of both Ditko characters. I thought the reprints in that issue were interesting. The inking on the story from AS 2 was exceptionally fine, although #5 was one of my least liked of the first 10 issues I suppose due to it not having an original villian.

    ReplyDelete
  8. D.Puck,

    I agree on ASM #5 being the least interesting of the first 10 issues. While it had some good bits in places, Dr. Doom was out of place and too powerful to take on Spider-Man. It makes sense as an attempt to acquire additional sales, and may have brought in a few readers of the Fantastic Four comic, but story wise it did not have the punch of new characters such as Dr. Octopus, Sandman and the Lizard (although the Living Brain story was a also a little weak).

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Spider-Man Annual #2 was always a favorite of mine-mainly because it had both of my favorite Ditko Marvel characters- years afterward I had the honor and pleasure of working on what could be considered a prequel to the annual's story- Kurt Busiek's Untold Tales of Spider-Man series contained stories that took place "in between" the regular series' original tales- he took that throwaway line of Spidey's in Annual #2,
    "This is beginning to feel like old times" as an indication that Doc and Spidey had met before- he then wrote a story wherein they had an adventure battling Mordo,with a behind the scenes appearance by Dormammu- we did this as a 48 page special Untold Tales called "Strange Encounters" - it was-IS-a highlight of my 30 something year old career- I've been a very lucky bastard...;o)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Neil,

    Thanks for sharing your story. I've enjoyed your work greatly over the years.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I always thought 5 had one of the weakest endings of the original run. It should have ended with some verbal confrontation of some sort. This was just a weird way to end the story.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Strangely, Nick, my blog-list link to your site is several months old, being the 'Steve Ditko and the Branding of Marvel' post, so your links don't seem to be getting updated anymore. Anyway, regarding the word 'friendship', perhaps it wasn't in bold originally and Stan had it redone (by a different hand) to give it more emphasis? It's interesting to note that the cover says 'The Wondrous Worlds of Doctor Strange!', yet the splash page says 'The Wondrous World of Doctor Strange!'

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Kid,

    That is likely the case. Since covers were usually produced last Stan probably just forgot the exact title

    Nick

    ReplyDelete